Once Upon A Crime | True Crime

Marie Hilley’s story is one of the strangest true crime cases ever recorded—filled with deception, betrayal, and shocking twists at every turn. What seemed like a typical Southern life masked a dark secret: a woman willing to poison those closest to her for personal gain. With so many unbelievable moments in this case, we’ve split it into two parts. In this episode, we explore the early crimes of Marie Hilley and the deadly path that led to her downfall.