The Simply Scary Podcast

Some places remember. Some desires never let go. In this spine-chilling episode of Chilling Tales for Dark Nights, host Geoff Sturtevant welcomes back Jay of Horror on the Rocks for a night of eerie, unforgettable storytelling. Two haunting tales await—one set on the open sea, where the past refuses to be forgotten, and another in the dim glow of a bar where temptation comes with an unthinkable price. As the line between reality and nightmare blurs, these stories will pull you deep into the unknown, where memory lingers like a ghost and every choice carries a cost. "When the Waves Remember" by Jay of Horror on the Rocks – Adrift on a battered ship in the wake of a brutal attack, four survivors are left with nothing but each other—and the weight of their past sins. As they drink to their survival, old wounds resurface, and the ocean itself seems to listen, waiting for its own form of reckoning. A harrowing tale of guilt, memory, and the inescapable tide of fate, this story will leave you wondering if some gho